By Lacy Baugher for Drama on April 3rd, 2013

Heads Up Sherlock Holmes Fans: Elementary Renewed For Season 2

elementary-10.jpg
CBS renewed their Sherlock Holmes adaptation Elementary for a second season this week, guaranteeing that Holmes enthusiasts everywhere will get at least one more year of the network’s genderbending adventures featuring stars Jonny Lee Miller and Lucy Liu.

The CBS drama picked up considerable buzz at the beginning of the US Fall TV season for their decision to turn John Watson into Joan in their interpretation of the stories featuring Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s great detective. While the actual series hasn’t done what could be called a terribly stringent job in adhering to the Conan Doyle canon, the detective drama has nevertheless managed to gather a sizeable audience on Thursday nights.

Elementary’s renewal isn’t surprising, given that it’s one of the most successful new dramas of the 2012-2013 television season, averaging somewhere around 10 million viewers per episode. While the show doesn’t recreate Conan Doyle stories in anything really approximating an accurate manner, it has started to bring in recognizable characters such as Sebastian Moran, James Moriarty and Irene Adler (sort of) in recent episodes, so canon fans can hope that this  interpretation may have at least a bit of Conan Doyle flavor going forward. Maybe. We hope?

Personally, I enjoy Miller’s performance as Holmes and generally find his acting decisions interesting, but a great deal of this show leaves me feeling disappointed. Liu’s Watson is pretty meh for me and the Holmes-Watson relationship has also been pretty weak, in my opinion, over the course of the season thus far. (To be fair, their interactions have generally improved as we’ve gone along, but I still don’t quite “buy” their friendship yet either.) But, I’m still about four episodes behind on Elementary all told, so maybe it improves dramatically at some point between there and now. Since I’ve not exactly been the most dedicated viewer of this show, I’d love to hear what those of you who are watching have to say – what do you think? Are you pleased it’s getting a second season? Would you recommend it to fellow Holmes enthusiasts?

By Lacy Baugher for Drama on April 3rd, 2013
Lacy Baugher

Lacy's love of British TV is embarrassingly extensive, but primarily centers around evangelizing all things Doctor Who, and watching as many period dramas as possible.

Digital media type by day, she also has a fairly useless degree in British medieval literature, and dearly loves to talk about dream poetry, liminality, and the medieval religious vision. (Sadly, that opportunity presents itself very infrequently.) York apologist, Ninth Doctor enthusiast, and unabashed Ravenclaw. Say hi on Threads or Blue Sky at @LacyMB. 

Explore More

More to Love from Telly Visions

  • British Actor Rhys Ifans to Play Elementary’s Mycroft Holmes

    CBS’s Sherlock Holmes adaptation Elementary continues its streak of making incredibly interesting casting choices for secondary roles – decisions that are just intriguing enough to make you come back to the show again and again even its actual stories are maybe not everything you might wish. (This is at least where I am with the series – I know many people love it and many can’t stand it. So clearly, your mileage may vary greatly with this particular crime drama.)

    They really are pretty good at pulling you back in right when think you’re out though. Well done, show.

    Elementary, which stars Jonny Lee Miller and Lucy Liu as Holmes and Watson, also seems to pride itself on its non-traditional casting and character decisions. Besides making Watson a woman, the show features a transgender Mrs. Hudson and cast Game of Thrones star Natalie Dormer as Irene Adler at the end of last season only to turn around and make her Moriarty by the finale. Now another British actor will be joining the mix – Rhys Ifans is set to play Sherlock’s older brother Mycroft Holmes when the show returns for its second season this Fall. And what kind of twist we might expect on this particular canon character is anyone’s guess.

    By Lacy Baugher for Drama on 7/2/2013

  • Elementary Gets Its Own Irene Adler: Natalie Dormer Set for Guest Role

    Just when you think you’re out, they pull you back in.

    That’s been largely my experience with CBS’ Sherlock Holmes adaptation Elementary – the two of us have certainly had a yo-yo sort of relationship. I expected to hate it. I did not. I love Jonny Lee Miller’s performance as Holmes. I don’t really believe in Lucy Liu’s Watson. I like some of the secondary characters. The generic mysteries of the week are dreadful, but on the rare occasions the show has actually attempted to use the Sir Arthur Conan Doyle cases as inspiration – the episode featuring the introduction of Sebastian Moran, for example – it’s actually quite interesting. The show rarely uses the Conan Doyle stories as inspiration.

    My internal back-and-forth on this issue is rather extensive. But, Elementary’s managed to hook me at least through the end of their first season, now that they’ve cast one of my favorite actresses as Holmes’s former flame Irene Adler. British actress Natalie Dormer has officially joined the cast for a three episode guest run – you’ve probably seen her as Margaery Tyrell on Game of Thrones or Anne Boleyn on The Tudors – and she is basically perfect for this part. Well, played show. I (reluctantly) tip my hat to you.

    By Lacy Baugher for Drama on 4/21/2013

  • Sherlock Holmes Series Elementary Gets a Full-Season Order From CBS: Four Things to Work On

    CBS announced yesterday that it’s giving a full-season order to its freshman drama series Elementary. This news isn’t a huge surprise - the modern-day Sherlock Holmes adaptation has been performing admirably for the network on Thursday nights. It’s the second most popular new series of the season and averages somewhere in the 11-14 million viewers per episode range, even if their demos do skew rather on the older side. (This is CBS though, so I’m sure that fact wasn’t terribly unexpected, either.)

    For many Sherlock Holmes enthusiasts, this is probably very welcome news – and I agree that more Holmes in any incarnation is almost always excellent. While Elementary did not turn out to be quite the trainwreck I had originally envisioned and I mostly enjoyed the pilot, personally, I’ve found its subsequent episodes to be somewhat mediocre. Since it’s now confirmed that we’ll be seeing a lot more of Jonny Lee Miller and Lucy Liu for the rest of the year – American seasons run for 22 episodes after all – there’s plenty of time for the show to work out its kinks. Here are a few suggestions.

    By Lacy Baugher for Drama on 10/24/2012